Loading... Please wait!

Loading...

When Debt Review Actually Makes Sense

When Debt Review Actually Makes Sense

By Gabriel Gonçalves · Published 17 November 2026

Key points

  • Debt review, also called debt counselling, is a legal process for people who are over-indebted: they can no longer keep up with what they owe, but still have some income left to pay.
  • It can lower your instalments and protect you from legal action by creditors while you stick to the plan.
  • The trade-off is real: you cannot take any new credit until all your short-term debt is paid off and you get a clearance certificate.
  • If your problem is one bad month, or one debt you can renegotiate yourself, debt review is probably too big a step.
Couple at home checking their bank balance on a laptop with a card in hand, reviewing their finances before deciding on debt review. Image by DC Studio on Freepik
Before choosing debt review, list every debt and check whether your instalments leave you short every month. (Image: DC Studio/Freepik)

When the debit orders bounce and the calls from creditors start, debt review can sound like a lifeline.

Sometimes it is. But it is also a commitment that can last for years, and once you are in, you cannot simply change your mind and borrow again.

We have read the National Credit Regulator’s guidance and the fee rules to answer one question honestly: when is debt review the right move, and when is it not?

Is debt review right for you?

The NCR is clear that “only over-indebted consumers can qualify”. At the same time, you need “a disposable income to enable negotiation for the reduction of installments”.

In plain terms: you must be struggling, but not so badly that there is nothing left to offer your creditors.

This comparison can help you see where you stand:

Debt review can make sense if…It probably does not if…
You owe several creditors and miss payments month after month.You had one bad month, for example after an unexpected bill.
Your instalments take so much of your income that you borrow to pay other debts.You have one debt you could renegotiate directly with the lender.
Creditors are threatening legal action or handing you over for collection.You plan to apply for a home loan or car finance soon.
You still have a regular income, even if it is not enough to cover everything.You have no income at the moment, so there is nothing to restructure.
You are ready to live without new credit for a few years.You rely on a credit card or store account for monthly essentials.

A useful test: if you added up all your debt instalments and they leave you short every single month, even after cutting what you can, it is worth speaking to a registered debt counsellor.

If the gap is small or temporary, try the alternatives further down first.

What happens once you apply, and what it costs

Debt review is not a quick fix. It follows a set path:

  1. Assessment. A registered debt counsellor looks at your income, expenses and debts to decide whether you are over-indebted. If you are not, the application is rejected.
  2. Creditors are notified. Your credit providers are told that you have applied for debt review.
  3. A new plan is proposed. The counsellor negotiates lower instalments, often over a longer period, and drafts a restructuring proposal.
  4. The plan is made legal. The proposal goes to a Magistrate’s Court or the National Consumer Tribunal to be confirmed.
  5. You pay one amount a month. The payment goes to a registered payment distribution agency, which pays your creditors. It does not go into the counsellor’s own account.

The costs

The NCR caps what debt counsellors can charge. According to its guidance, the application fee is R50 and the administration fee is R300.

The restructuring fee is equal to your first monthly instalment under the plan, up to R8,000 for one person, and an aftercare fee of 5% of the monthly amount, up to R450, is added after that.

For the full fee table and how to spot a counsellor who overcharges, see how to spot a debt review scam.

The part people forget

“Consumers cannot apply for, or be granted any new credit while they undergo debt counselling,” the NCR says.

You only become eligible again once your debt counsellor issues a clearance certificate.

For that, all your short-term debt, including car finance, credit cards, store cards and personal loans, must be paid off. If you have a home loan, its payments must be up to date.

In practice, that can take years. Be wary of anyone who promises big savings: the NCR has warned about adverts promising monthly savings of “about 60%”.

What to try before debt review

If you are not yet at the point where every month ends in the red, these steps cost nothing and keep your options open:

  • Call your creditors yourself. Many lenders will agree to a payment arrangement if you contact them before an account goes into arrears. Ask for the new terms in writing.
  • List every debt. Write down each balance, interest rate and instalment. Seeing it on paper often shows which debt is causing most of the damage.
  • Pay the most expensive debt first. Store cards and credit cards usually charge the highest rates. Clearing one can free up money for the rest.
  • Cut back before you borrow more. A new loan to pay old debts only helps if it is cheaper overall. Check that any consolidation loan stays within the legal limits on interest and fees.
  • Check your credit report. It shows every account in your name, so nothing is left out of your plan. You can get your free credit report once a year.

How to choose a debt counsellor

If you decide debt review is the right step, choose the counsellor yourself rather than answering a cold call or a WhatsApp message:

  1. Ask for the counsellor’s NCRDC registration number and check it on the NCR’s register of debt counsellors.
  2. Ask for a written breakdown of every fee and compare it with the NCR’s caps.
  3. Make sure your monthly payment goes to a registered payment distribution agency, never to the counsellor’s personal account.
  4. Ask for copies of your application, the restructuring proposal and the court order. The NCR advises consumers to ask for these documents.

How we checked this information

The eligibility rules, the restriction on new credit, the exit conditions and the fee caps come from the National Credit Regulator’s media release on debt counselling and its published fee guidance.

Where NCR documents give different fee caps, we used the most recent one. Sources checked on 17 November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Can I get new credit while under debt review?
No. While you are under debt review, you cannot apply for or be granted new credit. That restriction stays until your debt counsellor issues a clearance certificate.
Can I leave debt review whenever I want?
Not simply by changing your mind. According to the NCR, you exit once all your short-term debt is paid and you receive a clearance certificate. Anyone offering to "remove" debt review for a fee should be treated with suspicion.
Will debt review stop creditors from suing me?
The NCR describes debt counselling as a relief measure that protects consumers from legal action by credit providers, as long as you keep to the plan.
Is debt review the same as debt consolidation?
No. Debt consolidation is a new loan that pays off your old debts. Debt review restructures your existing debts through a legal process and stops you taking new credit until you finish.

This article is for information only and is not financial advice. Speak to a registered debt counsellor about your own situation.

Sources

Escrito por
Gabriel

Gabriel is a journalist and personal finance writer who specialises in turning economic news into practical money decisions. He holds a degree in Communications from Unicamp and a postgraduate degree in Journalism, and is completing a master’s in Culture and Communication at the University of Lisbon. His work focuses on clear, data-backed guides that help readers understand what price changes really cost them and what to do next.